Originally hailed as a landmark regulation that would combat the global scourge of forest loss.
But, the final version of the EU's deforestation regulation, once heralded as the crown jewel of the European Green Deal, has emerged in a significantly diluted state, prompting criticism from its original architect and environmental politicians.
"The regulation was stripped," said Hugo Schally, citing the exclusion of key obligations for downstream traders to verify the provenance of products like coffee, cocoa, beef, soy, palm oil, rubber and timber.
Schally cautioned that a reduced number of responsible companies, fewer data points, and imprecise sourcing details would hinder monitoring and legal action.
A Watered-Down Law
Environmental vice-president a leading green politician went further, describing the postponements, exceptions and new loopholes – such as one for paper goods – as the "systematic weakening" of the law.
This final text is a far cry from the hopes of more than a million European citizens who signed a petition in 2020 demanding a ban on deforestation-linked products.
When launched in 2021, then-Green Deal commissioner Frans Timmermans trumpeted it as "the most ambitious law ever put forward to fight forest loss."
A Story of Dilution
The regulation's dilution has been interpreted as the European Union retreating from its environmental promises. It faced significant delays, ostensibly over technical problems, which drew condemnation.
"By reopening this file rather than fixing a technical issue, authorities invited political interference," remarked the Green MEP.
Originally, the law required companies to track commodities back to their exact plot of land using geolocation data, holding them accountable for deforestation in their supply chains with penalties and large financial penalties.
"It wasn't bureaucracy for its own sake," Schally said. "It was the mechanism that made the rules enforceable, created a verifiable paper trail, and stopped companies from hiding behind opaque production networks."
Mounting Pressure
Yet, the strict due diligence triggered a backlash in the EU capital from multinational corporations, producer countries, conservative political groups and member states with forestry industries.
Analysts point to last year's European Parliament elections as a decisive moment, creating a new political majority more skeptical of green regulations.
"The other pressure came from big trading partners like the United States," noted corporate sustainability professor, implying the commission gave in to some demands in trade talks.
The Weakened Final Text
The passed law includes key dilutions:
- Retailers and traders were largely freed from conducting rigorous checks.
- A new “low risk” category was created.
- A window for further "simplifications" was opened for next spring.
- Only a handful of nations – Russia, Belarus, North Korea and Myanmar – will face “high risk” scrutiny.
"Instead of tightening downstream obligations, it stripped them back," lamented Schally. "Moving obligations to producers, it lessened the number of responsible firms."
Business Frustration
The protracted process and revisions have also caused frustration for businesses that complied early.
"We feel very annoyed because we invested significant resources into preparing," stated a coffee company executive. "We purchased systems, trained staff and established procedures... now they’re saying it could be altered again. It’s a big frustration."
The Commission's Stance
A commission spokesperson supported the final law, saying: "We have listened to feedback and taken action to ensure a pragmatic and balanced application."
"The new text provides for predictability, which is crucial for companies and national regulators to successfully implement this very important law."